Commercial Director or CFO: What do SMEs need?

(ex: Photo by

Aditya Naidu

on

Commercial Director or CFO: What do SMEs need?

7

Morten Laufer

Founder

Commercial Director and CFO are not the same thing: the difference lies in the statutory appointment and company size. Here, you'll find duties, distinctions, job descriptions, and budgets. Nova Search places CFO and finance roles in medium-sized businesses, delivering a shortlist in 5 business days.

Topics on this page
The topic briefly and compactly
  • Commercial Director and CFO differ primarily in legal terms: the CFO role is an executive body mandate with personal liability.

  • StepStone cites a median salary of €72,200 for Commercial Directors in Munich, with a range from €62,700 to €84,000.

  • Treuenfels puts the starting salary at €95,000 gross and the top salary at €150,000 gross.

  • Rule of thumb: up to around 100 employees a Commercial Director, from around 1,000 employees, a corporate group structure or investors it becomes a CFO.

  • Nova Search fills CFO, Finance Manager and Financial Accounting roles in SMEs, initial shortlist in 5 business days.

What does a Commercial Director do?

In medium-sized businesses, the Commercial Director (Kaufmännischer Leiter) is the central authority for finance, controlling and administration. They hold specialist and operational responsibility for all commercial functions that support, manage and document the business. In concrete terms, this means planning the corporate budget and monitoring adherence to financial targets, analysing business KPIs and preparing management reports, overseeing accounting, and developing cost-reduction strategies.

Broad responsibility rather than a pure finance focus

In SMEs (Mittelstand), an additional block of responsibilities is included that is typically managed separately in corporate group structures: HR, IT, legal, insurance, and sometimes procurement. Where these areas are bundled together, the role is usually called Commercial Director. The title signals breadth, not necessarily greater depth in the finance function. The scope varies widely: the exact same job title can refer to leading a pure accounting team of four people, or holding overall commercial responsibility for a company of 800 employees with statutory power of attorney (Prokura).

  • Budget planning and control: Planning the corporate budget and monitoring compliance with financial targets

  • Controlling and reporting: Analysing business KPIs and preparing reports for senior management

  • Accounting and financial statements: Overseeing day-to-day accounting, responsible for monthly, quarterly, and annual financial statements in accordance with the German Commercial Code (HGB)

  • Liquidity and external relations: Payment transactions, cash flow planning, negotiations with banks, shareholders, and insurers

  • Cost reduction and process optimisation: Implementing efficient processes and strategies for cost optimisation

  • Additionally in SMEs: HR, IT, legal, and insurance, often procurement as well

In terms of qualifications, the market expects a degree in business or economics with a focus on accounting, tax, or finance, or alternatively commercial training supplemented by certification as a Certified Management Accountant (Bilanzbuchhalter). This is paired with leadership experience and a confident command of business software tools. Important for you as an employer: the Commercial Director is responsible for ensuring the company complies with statutory regulations and can be held liable in the event of breaches, particularly concerning contract design, product liability, and employment law.

Is a Commercial Director a CFO?

The decisive distinction is not the title, but the corporate body status (Organstellung). A Head of Finance is an employee with statutory power of attorney (Prokura under Section 48 HGB) and is generally only liable within the framework of employment law limitations of liability. A CFO holds a formal board or managing director mandate with statutory executive status, making them personally and unconditionally liable—for example, for delayed insolvency filings, unpaid social security contributions, and tax debts. Functionally, making the leap changes less than the title change suggests: someone who already signs off on accounts, negotiates with banks, and manages liquidity often does the exact same work as an SME CFO, supplemented by decisions on capital structure and strategic matters such as acquisitions, succession planning, or bringing in investors.

Criterion

Commercial Director

CFO

Legal status

Employee with Prokura, no executive board mandate

Managing Director or Executive Board mandate with statutory status

Liability

Employment law limitations of liability

Personal, unlimited liability under stock corporation or GmbH law

Typical company size

Up to approx. 100 employees

From approx. 1,000 employees upwards, or in corporate/capital-market-oriented structures

Scope

Finance plus HR, IT, legal, insurance

Capital structure, financing, strategic topics such as M&A and investors

Reporting line

To executive management

Part of executive management / on the Board

Between 100 and 1,000 employees, the title Head of Finance (Leiter Finanzen) generally prevails, frequently alongside a separate controlling function. From around 1,000 employees upwards—and at the latest when adopting group structures or approaching the capital markets—the position becomes a CFO with an executive board mandate. Because exceptions abound, you should never look at the title alone, but at three criteria: reporting line, legal signing authority, and the scope of the assigned departments.

When does an SME need a CFO?

The right time for a CFO depends less on headcount than on the complexity facing the finance function. Typical triggers include growth plans, succession or equity participation models, or multiple entities that need to be structured and integrated. Added to this is reporting to investors and banks whenever transparency must be established. From our recruitment practice: for CFO positions, the managing directors or owners are typically the primary client contacts. The decision is therefore made at owner/executive level, and that is precisely where it should be prepared.

How do you advertise the role?

A good job description determines whether qualified candidates apply in the first place. The template from Workwise demonstrates the components that have proven effective.

  1. Introductory text: Briefly introduce the company, products, values, and core requirements of the role before listing the tasks

  2. Define the tone of address: Tailor the formality of address to the target group and corporate culture; there is a noticeable trend towards an informal address, and templates exist in both styles

  3. Describe tasks and daily routines realistically: Giving insights into day-to-day responsibilities clarifies expectations rather than inflating a wishlist of requirements

  4. Define non-negotiables: Pin down the two or three must-have criteria without which the role cannot function—such as HGB financial statement sign-off, leadership experience, or readiness to hold Prokura

One element not reflected in standard templates, yet critical to success or failure, is the employer pitch. Profitable mid-sized companies are often not widely known as employers, whereas well-known consumer brands naturally attract applicants. Such SMEs rely heavily on delivering a compelling pitch to candidates. In a job advert, this means concretely: why is this role rewarding at your firm, what is the scope of impact, and how direct is the reporting line to the executive board? Answering these questions right in the intro makes up for any lack of brand awareness.

What budget should you plan for?

Salary data for this role varies considerably, as company size, region, and Prokura authority significantly alter its scope. For budget planning, you should compare three reference sources side by side.

Source

Salary indication for Commercial Director

StepStone Munich

Median €72,200, range €62,700 to €84,000

Profiling Institut, Head of Finance (Germany, 2026)

Median €98,500, range €72,000 to €160,000

Treuenfels Personalberatung

Starting salary €95,000, top tier €150,000

Stepping up to a CFO comes with a noticeable premium: with executive board status, not only does personal liability increase, but the salary level also rises substantially above the brackets for Commercial Directors. How high this premium is in individual cases depends on company size, industry, and the variable component. We address specific CFO salary benchmarks in a dedicated article on CFO salaries.

Alongside the base salary, you should factor in fringe benefits. For C-level positions, the variable component is often tied to company performance and typically makes up 20 to 50 percent of the base salary. On top of that come classic mid-market perks like a company car and a company pension scheme. Calculating the total package realistically helps avoid the classic trap: setting the budget too tightly, receiving rejections from suitable candidates, and having to restart the search from scratch.

Once you have defined the role and established the budget, the focus shifts to speed and precision in the search. That is precisely where Nova Search comes in: we fill CFO, Finance Manager, and financial accounting roles via permanent recruitment—complete with briefing, two-stage screening, and a first qualified shortlist within 5 working days, protected by our 90-day guarantee.

Sources

FAQ

Is a Commercial Director a CFO?

Not automatically. The Commercial Director is an employee, usually with commercial power of attorney (Prokura), and is responsible for finance, controlling, HR, and administration. The CFO holds a corporate mandate as Managing Director or Executive Board member with personal liability, and makes autonomous decisions on capital structure and financing. Functionally, the work is often similar in SMEs, but legally it is not.

How much does a Commercial Director earn?

StepStone reports a median gross salary of €72,200 for Commercial Directors in Munich, with a range between €62,700 and €84,000. Treuenfels cites a starting salary of €95,000 and top salaries of up to €150,000. The Profiling Institut puts the median for heads of finance at €98,500, with a range from €72,000 to €160,000, depending on company size and authority.

When does an SME need a CFO instead of a Commercial Director?

Typical triggers include growth financing, succession or equity participation models, multiple legal entities, investor reporting, or an upcoming transaction. As a rule of thumb: up to around 100 employees, a Commercial Director is sufficient; between 100 and 1,000, a Head of Finance; and from around 1,000 employees or with a corporate group structure, a CFO with a corporate mandate is required.

How much does a CFO cost in an SME?

Significantly more than a Commercial Director: with the corporate mandate and strategic responsibility, the salary level rises considerably, supplemented by variable bonuses that often range between 20 and 50 per cent of the base salary. We cover specific salary bands based on company size in a dedicated article on CFO salaries.

What should be included in a Commercial Director job description?

An introductory text briefly presenting the company, products, and values; realistic insights into the tasks and daily work routine; the essential criteria; and a tone of voice that fits your culture. Workwise offers templates in both informal and formal address. If your employer brand is less well known, the pitch determines the quality and volume of applications, not the job title.

What qualifications does a Commercial Director have?

A degree in business administration or commercial vocational training combined with professional experience in leadership roles is typical. Analytical thinking, strong negotiation skills, and clear communication as the interface between departments and executive management are in demand, as well as confident handling of business tools.

How quickly can a Head of Finance role be filled?

The candidate market in finance and accounting is tight, and experienced profiles are rarely actively looking for a job. Traditional job advertisements therefore often take several months to fill. Working with a specialist search firm is significantly faster: Nova Search delivers the first qualified shortlist within 5 working days following the briefing and two-stage screening.

Cta Image

Book your free consultation